Are You Afraid of the Dark?Are You Afraid of the Dark?

Izzy's twin sister Grace has been acting strange, and when Izzy finds out Grace has been hanging out with the mysterious Midnight Society, she threatens to tell their parents. But the Midnight Society proposes a scare-off! If Izzy wins, Grace is booted from the group. If Grace wins, Izzy won't tell anyone about the society. What follows are three terrifying tales that determine the girls' fate.